App Store Reject

Guideline 5.2.5

Guideline 5.2.5 - Legal: App Confusingly Similar to Apple Product

Medium RiskMedium DifficultyTypical Fix: 1-3 days0 Reports
Also known as:App icon confusingly similar to Apple system app iconApp name creates misleading association with Apple productsInterface replicates Apple system app designApp appears to be made by Apple or is a system featureUse of Apple-trademarked terms or design patterns

Our Take

Apple is rejecting your app because its design, name, icon, or interface is confusingly similar to an existing Apple product, feature, or interface element. Under guideline 5.2.5, apps should not appear to be made by Apple or create confusion with Apple's own products and design language. Common triggers include: (1) using an app icon that closely resembles an Apple system app icon (Settings gear, Safari compass, Messages bubble), (2) naming the app with Apple-trademarked terms ('iSomething,' 'Apple Something,' names that begin with the Apple product naming convention), (3) replicating the look and feel of Apple system apps like Calculator, Weather, Clock, or Notes with near-identical UI, or (4) using Apple's proprietary design elements like the San Francisco system font weight combinations, specific color palettes, or layout patterns that make the app appear to be a system app. Apple is protective of user trust in their brand. If a user could reasonably believe your app is made by Apple or is a system feature, the rejection will stand.

Resolution Guide

01

**Redesign the app icon** — Create a distinct icon that doesn't resemble any Apple system app icon. Use different colors, shapes, and visual metaphors. Don't use gear icons, compass icons, or speech bubbles in Apple's style.


02

**Rename the app** — Remove any Apple-trademarked terms. Avoid names starting with 'i' followed by a capital letter (iPhoto, iMovie pattern), 'Apple,' 'Mac,' 'iOS,' or names of Apple products/features.


03

**Differentiate the UI** — If your app's interface looks like a system app, add distinctive branding: custom colors, your logo, unique navigation patterns, or a different visual style. The user should immediately know this isn't a system app.


04

**Review Apple's trademark list** — Check developer.apple.com/legal/intellectual-property for a list of Apple trademarks. Ensure your app doesn't use any of them.


05

**Add your brand identity** — Include your own company logo, brand colors, and distinctive design elements prominently in the app.

Prevention

  • Design a strong, unique brand identity before development
  • Avoid 'i' prefix naming conventions
  • Don't use Apple system app icons as design references for your icon
  • Review Apple's trademark guidelines during the naming process

    • Example Rejection Email

    From:Apple App Review Team
    Subject:Guideline 5.2.5 - Legal: App Confusingly Similar to Apple
    Guideline 5.2.5 - Legal - Intellectual Property Your app or its metadata creates a misleading association with Apple products, features, or interfaces. Specifically, your app's [icon/name/interface/design] is confusingly similar to Apple's [specific product or feature]. Users may be confused into believing this app is an official Apple product. Next Steps: Please update your app to differentiate it clearly from Apple products. This includes: 1. Changing the app icon to be visually distinct from Apple system app icons. 2. Removing Apple-trademarked terms from the app name. 3. Modifying the UI design to be clearly distinguishable from Apple's system interfaces.

    Consider Appealing

    Appeal is generally not viable unless the similarity is superficial and your app has a strong, distinct brand identity. If appealing, emphasize how your app's design is distinct and provide screenshots showing the differences.

    Generate Appeal

    Before & After

    Before — Rejected

    Calculator app with an icon nearly identical to Apple's Calculator app icon (orange gradient with +/= symbol), named 'iCalculator Pro,' with a UI that mirrors Apple's Calculator layout pixel-for-pixel

    After — Approved

    App renamed to 'CalcMaster Pro' with a distinctive blue icon featuring the company logo; UI uses custom colors, rounded card layouts, and branded header — clearly not a system app

    What changed: Apps must establish their own visual identity. Copying Apple's design creates user confusion and trademark issues.

    Community Solutions · 0

    Sign in to share your solution.

    More Guideline 5 (Legal) rejections

    View all Guideline 5 rejections